Lawyers and recruiters reject paralegal’s advice to law grads on avoiding retail experience

Avatar photo

By Legal Cheek on

21

LinkedIn post triggers strong reaction


A paralegal’s advice against working in retail or hospitality for those seeking top graduate roles in law has sparked criticism from many legal professionals on LinkedIn.

The law grad argues in a recent LinkedIn post that retail and hospitality work “doesn’t teach you the important transferable skills”, and that instead, “you need to show basic tech and emailing skills” acquired through office work.

“If you are getting angry thinking ‘well I couldn’t land that job so had to work retail’ … the answer is you should have thought about the job before you started university,” they say. For those who don’t have an office role secured, “take a gap year — secure work experience and then go into education”.

The paralegal, who we have chosen not to name, concludes with: “At the end of the day it’s much easier to take a loan out and blame your lack of employment on studies.”

The full post, screenshotted below, now appears to have been deleted.

The advice hasn’t gone down well with lawyers and graduate recruiters alike.

Law firm associate, and legal LinkedInfluencer Jen Shipley hit back saying that “As someone who hires graduates into legal roles, for me it’s a green light when I see that a candidate has retail or hospitality experience”, before recounting how beneficial her own retail experience was.

Others who have questioned the advice include several associates and partners, senior barristers and judges, legal recruiters, and a host of current and future trainees.

Samantha Hope, Shoosmiths‘ head of emerging talent, said that she “wholeheartedly” disagreed but “well done on creating a clickbait post”. She continued: “Unfortunately these types of posts, that seek out to gain comments on clear controversy, might garner engagement, but you’ll gain very little respect.”

Another simply added that, “this is up there with the absolute worst advice I have ever seen”.

The paralegal declined to comment on the post’s reaction.

 The 2025 Legal Cheek Firms Most List

21 Comments

Dismayed

He said what partners at law firms were thinking…..wrong but prevalent belief

Private Practice to in-house 20 years

Then they and you have fundamentally failed to understand that the legal profession is a service business. The client user experience is ultimately what differentiates who they will instruct again. Retail and hospitality can teach so much in this regard.

Something Clever

As a partner in a law firm who worked in hospitality before getting a TC…this is absolute nonsense.

Disisreality

I am so jealous of our US partners who no longer have to play along with the silly woke agenda. We have to last it out until the next election which will feel like an eternity. The only retail jobs that help an application are at the better auction houses.

Legallylexy

Silly woke agenda?

JimGower85

Jen Shipley fighting the easy fight. When will these legal influencers actually do something productive and take on the SRA about SQE costs?

Ban All Legal Influencers

Having seen the original post, I’m not surprised it came from yet another cringe legal influencer

Ilyas

SQE cost is out of touch, and it seems noone is brave enough to stand against the SRA and challenge the cost.

Fell For It Again Award

Rage bait

Greg Roy

Turns out this was indeed a very touchy subject for you all. I actually agree with this person

Laughing loudly in Berlin airport

the absolute epitome of “legal influencer” clickbait nonsense

strong “tell me you don’t work in graduate recruitment without telling me you don’t” vibe

having seen the original post, I noted the person in question doesn’t have a training contract, nor has completed any vacation schemes.

which is of course fine – it’s hard out there – but maybe not in the best position to be dispensing careers advice

7 years' PQE

Those who can’t, teach. /s

But in all seriousness, yes, it does seem odd that people who haven’t achieved the thing they are preaching about themselves feel the need to tell others how to do it.

Confused

If this paralegal knows so much about what is required to make a strong TC application, why are they not doing a training contract right now?

🏆

And this person wins the prize! ☝️

Idle barrister

She got what she wanted, attention! Can we stop giving such so called “influencers” any kind of recognition

Ariyan

I think everyone has a right to share their views. But some people like to
Judge others. Can we really stop judging and being apple polisher.

In my idea, this person does express their feelings to the current job sector why some of you attack him/her. Just because they did not write same as others on LinkedIn ” I am delighted to share …”. As I said, everyone has freedom of speech and stop being sarcastic!

Oceangate Titan

“competative” and “persue”

Yes. I can see the poster has taken their own advice and acquired basic emailing and office skills.

Then screenshotting and posting on LI?Embarrassing

Richard

When I last ran a pupillage recruitment process I awarded extra marks in the criteria for people who had had to work their way through their studies doing any sort of job in recognition of the extra burden on them.

I myself worked from the age of 16 to 21 as a lifeguard at 2 (consecutive) leisure centres. I also ran children’s birthday parties and summer activity programmes. I’ve no idea how I managed to get plastered on Friday and Saturday nights yet still cycle to work for an 8am start to a 10 hour day. Youth! Where have you abandoned me?

As we might now say from our ivory towers: it taught me to understand ordinary people.

I did do data entry for the CPS one summer, presumably our unsuccessful paralegal would approve of that..

I’m quite sure it made me a more rounded person and gave

Thomas

I chose the profession because it meant I never had to deal with “ordinary people”, let alone try to understand them.

Kirkland associate

I love taking advice from such an established paralegal who has worked “10 hour days in a fast paced law firm environment” !

(At a high street firm)

Idontcareifyoudontlikeme

Don’t knock it, they sometimes are working on 6 figure deals.

Join the conversation

Related Stories

Law graduate rejected for a paralegal role vents frustration on LinkedIn

'While I respect the firm's selection process...'

Jan 3 2025 9:41am
45
Irwin Mitchell's Jen Shipley

Law ‘SuperInfluencer’ Jen Shipley’s LinkedIn posts worth £300k, marketing guru claims

D&I advocate Justin Farance social media clout valued at nearly £200k

Nov 28 2024 8:53am
19
computer man meme

‘What is going on with legal LinkedIn?’ 

One lawyer isn't happy

Nov 8 2024 8:52am
24