‘Inaccurate’ media lead to judicial death threats, says Lady Chief Justice

Avatar photo

By Rhys Duncan on

2

Baroness Carr calls for ‘objective and accurate reporting’


“Inaccurate reporting” has led to judges receiving death threats and being “doorstepped,” the Lady Chief Justice warned — just days after a new survey revealed that many judges now fear for their personal safety.

Speaking to the House of Lords constitution committee, Baroness Carr added to her previous comment that she was “deeply troubled” by an exchange during Prime Ministers’ Questions where the PM claimed that a judge had made the “wrong decision” in relation to an immigration appeal. This, she said, was a misunderstanding of the case.

“To imply, for example, that a Palestinian family was allowed to settle in this country under the Ukrainian family scheme is simply, wholly wrong,” she said. “But as a result of that headline and the publicity, without going into details or individuals, there have been extraordinarily serious security threats.”

“It’s really important to understand that no one has ever suggested, no one is saying there should not be robust and healthy debate both in and outside parliament, including criticism if necessary of judgments,” she continued. “But the judicial process and judicial independence have to be respected.”

Carr added that if the judgment is wrong the litigants have the option to appeal, however if the law itself is deemed to be wrong, that is the realm of parliament to change.

Whilst debating a judgment is fair game, Carr said, “Inaccurate reporting and abuse of a judge who cannot speak out to defend themselves” is unacceptable. “The trigger for my concern in the context of the need to respect the judicial process is the dangers that arise out of inaccurate reporting.”

 The 2025 Legal Cheek Firms Most List

The committee were told that judges have received death threats and been doorstepped. One judge, Carr said, had been contacted on social media by someone who claimed threateningly that he was standing next to the judge’s child on a bus.

“I welcome reporting and criticism but what I have always asked for, from day one, is fair, objective and accurate reporting,” Carr told the committee.

“This is not about closing the debate down,” she said. “The debate should be wide open. It is for the courts to decide whether a judgment is wrong. But it is absolutely unacceptable — as I must protect my judges and defend them — that they are exposed to the sort of comments and reporting that shatter their lives.”

A recent survey of judges in the UK found that nearly four in ten judges (39%) are now worried about their safety in court, with 26% concerned outside of court.

As a response, Carr continued, the courts and judiciary have taken protection action. “They change the way we work on a day-to-day basis now, she said. “We are taking steps — which I cannot divulge or share — on a daily basis in relation to where we do things and how we do things.”

2 Comments

Anonymous

Not reading. I do not consider Baroness Hale a credible authority.

The person above is clearly an idiot

Er… it’s Baroness Carr.

Fool!

Join the conversation

Related Stories

Robot
news SQE Hub

Kaplan’s use of AI for SQE ‘question development’ comes under scrutiny amid US Bar row

Company informs Legal Cheek that no questions generated by AI are used in SQE assessments

3 days ago
8
People using social media on their mobile phones

The best social media posts of the week 

A round-up of online musings, memes and more

3 days ago

Liverpool, Glasgow, Southampton and Warwick law students celebrated at latest Pro Bono Awards

Projects include a Windrush app, sexual violence legal advice and a law-themed classroom outreach

3 days ago

Fancy becoming a Supreme Court justice?

You’ll need ‘sound judgment and decisiveness’

4 days ago
1

UAE turns to AI to draft the laws of the future

Making legislative system 'faster and more precise'

5 days ago
12
careers SQE Hub

How to break into a US law firm — without leaving the UK

Claire Flores, head of student sales at BARBRI, discusses qualifying via the SQE, the global appeal of US law firms, and how aspiring solicitors can stand out in a competitive market

6 days ago

What inheritance tax changes really mean for farmers

Exeter law grad Harry Cooke analyses budget changes to agricultural property relief that sparked protests around the country

6 days ago
4

Bank Holiday round-up

The top legal affairs news stories from the long weekend

6 days ago

Law student drops legal action over Birmingham bin strikes

Open University student withdraws case after receiving written assurances from the union about adherence to picketing rules

Apr 17 2025 8:52am
14

Digital inheritance: Who gets your Bitcoin and Instagram profile? 

SQE student Olga Kyriakoudi delves into the legal challenges of inheriting digital assets

Apr 17 2025 8:52am
2

Supreme Court rules ‘woman’ has biological meaning

Top judges unanimous decision that ‘man’ and ‘woman’ in UK equality legislation mean biological sex

Apr 16 2025 12:41pm
43

Judges given guidance on spotting AI-generated submissions

Unfamiliar case names and US spellings among key giveaways

Apr 16 2025 11:40am
1

Ukraine calls in Hogan Lovells for US minerals deal

Washington partners drafted in

Apr 16 2025 8:50am

New docu-series exploring the lives of criminal barristers premieres tonight

Essential viewing for criminal bar hopefuls

Apr 15 2025 11:15am
3

A&O Shearman, Kirkland, and Latham among latest firms to strike deals with Trump

President's pro bono haul exceeds £700 million

Apr 14 2025 11:29am
25
Robot
news SQE Hub

Kaplan’s use of AI for SQE ‘question development’ comes under scrutiny amid US Bar row

Company informs Legal Cheek that no questions generated by AI are used in SQE assessments

3 days ago
8
People using social media on their mobile phones

The best social media posts of the week 

A round-up of online musings, memes and more

3 days ago

Liverpool, Glasgow, Southampton and Warwick law students celebrated at latest Pro Bono Awards

Projects include a Windrush app, sexual violence legal advice and a law-themed classroom outreach

3 days ago

Fancy becoming a Supreme Court justice?

You’ll need ‘sound judgment and decisiveness’

4 days ago
1

UAE turns to AI to draft the laws of the future

Making legislative system 'faster and more precise'

5 days ago
12
careers SQE Hub

How to break into a US law firm — without leaving the UK

Claire Flores, head of student sales at BARBRI, discusses qualifying via the SQE, the global appeal of US law firms, and how aspiring solicitors can stand out in a competitive market

6 days ago

What inheritance tax changes really mean for farmers

Exeter law grad Harry Cooke analyses budget changes to agricultural property relief that sparked protests around the country

6 days ago
4

Bank Holiday round-up

The top legal affairs news stories from the long weekend

6 days ago

Law student drops legal action over Birmingham bin strikes

Open University student withdraws case after receiving written assurances from the union about adherence to picketing rules

Apr 17 2025 8:52am
14

Digital inheritance: Who gets your Bitcoin and Instagram profile? 

SQE student Olga Kyriakoudi delves into the legal challenges of inheriting digital assets

Apr 17 2025 8:52am
2

Supreme Court rules ‘woman’ has biological meaning

Top judges unanimous decision that ‘man’ and ‘woman’ in UK equality legislation mean biological sex

Apr 16 2025 12:41pm
43

Judges given guidance on spotting AI-generated submissions

Unfamiliar case names and US spellings among key giveaways

Apr 16 2025 11:40am
1

Ukraine calls in Hogan Lovells for US minerals deal

Washington partners drafted in

Apr 16 2025 8:50am

New docu-series exploring the lives of criminal barristers premieres tonight

Essential viewing for criminal bar hopefuls

Apr 15 2025 11:15am
3

A&O Shearman, Kirkland, and Latham among latest firms to strike deals with Trump

President's pro bono haul exceeds £700 million

Apr 14 2025 11:29am
25
Robot
news SQE Hub

Kaplan’s use of AI for SQE ‘question development’ comes under scrutiny amid US Bar row

Company informs Legal Cheek that no questions generated by AI are used in SQE assessments

3 days ago
8
People using social media on their mobile phones

The best social media posts of the week 

A round-up of online musings, memes and more

3 days ago

Liverpool, Glasgow, Southampton and Warwick law students celebrated at latest Pro Bono Awards

Projects include a Windrush app, sexual violence legal advice and a law-themed classroom outreach

3 days ago

Fancy becoming a Supreme Court justice?

You’ll need ‘sound judgment and decisiveness’

4 days ago
1

UAE turns to AI to draft the laws of the future

Making legislative system 'faster and more precise'

5 days ago
12
careers SQE Hub

How to break into a US law firm — without leaving the UK

Claire Flores, head of student sales at BARBRI, discusses qualifying via the SQE, the global appeal of US law firms, and how aspiring solicitors can stand out in a competitive market

6 days ago

What inheritance tax changes really mean for farmers

Exeter law grad Harry Cooke analyses budget changes to agricultural property relief that sparked protests around the country

6 days ago
4

Bank Holiday round-up

The top legal affairs news stories from the long weekend

6 days ago

Law student drops legal action over Birmingham bin strikes

Open University student withdraws case after receiving written assurances from the union about adherence to picketing rules

Apr 17 2025 8:52am
14

Digital inheritance: Who gets your Bitcoin and Instagram profile? 

SQE student Olga Kyriakoudi delves into the legal challenges of inheriting digital assets

Apr 17 2025 8:52am
2

Supreme Court rules ‘woman’ has biological meaning

Top judges unanimous decision that ‘man’ and ‘woman’ in UK equality legislation mean biological sex

Apr 16 2025 12:41pm
43

Judges given guidance on spotting AI-generated submissions

Unfamiliar case names and US spellings among key giveaways

Apr 16 2025 11:40am
1

Ukraine calls in Hogan Lovells for US minerals deal

Washington partners drafted in

Apr 16 2025 8:50am

New docu-series exploring the lives of criminal barristers premieres tonight

Essential viewing for criminal bar hopefuls

Apr 15 2025 11:15am
3

A&O Shearman, Kirkland, and Latham among latest firms to strike deals with Trump

President's pro bono haul exceeds £700 million

Apr 14 2025 11:29am
25